Carrier Vs Goodman: Which To Choose?

Carrier and Goodman both make a great HVAC system. However, it can be hard to choose which brand is good for you. When buying a new HVAC unit, it's always been a great idea to have a reference before purchasing.

If you want a high-quality AC unit, Carrier is the best option. However, Carrier is expensive and requires a complex installation process, so that's something to consider.

In contrast, a Goodman is another great choice if you want a cheaper AC unit. These units will last for years and come with a warranty that rivals other well-known brands like Carrier.

Because an air conditioning unit is one of your home's vital pieces of equipment, picking the right company to install yours is crucial. Continue reading as we touch on both brands below and other questions people have. With that said, let's dive right in!

Carrier and goodman air conditioning outside the building, Carrier Vs Goodman: Which To Choose?

Carrier And Goodman Reviews

Carrier is on top among many HVAC brands and holds great credit for designing and making high-quality HVAC products.

Since 1915, it's well known for its energy-efficient designs and high-quality products such as air conditioners,  furnaces, and heat pumps.

In contrast, Goodman air conditioners are another of the best HVAC maker on this list. They are also known for decades of trusted and reliable good service to their clients since 1975.

Furthermore, Goodman also offers vastly high-class yet budget-friendly products.

Air Conditioners

Carrier air conditioning units are among the most energy-efficient brands in the market. One of their known models, Infinity 24VNA6, has a 26 'Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio' (SEER) rating and around 16.5 (EER).

The Goodman GVXC20 model serves a 24.5 (SEER) and has a variable-speed electronically commutated motor (ECM).

Also, it can perform with high fan speeds, from 0% to 100%, based on your airflow demand.

Heat Pumps

Carrier's premier 25VNA4 heat pumps feature a Greenspeed Intelligence. This heat pump has a variable-speed compressor.

As a result, it helps to keep the exact amount of cooling required for your home's present conditions. In addition, it has a 24 SEER rating and 13 HSPF and guarantees 50% quieter than any other brand.

While Goodman heat pumps have a respected name as a mid-range brand, other high-end models may be more good. They also have a good warranty policy to protect your system if something goes wrong.

The GVZC20 high-efficiency split system is Goodman's best heat pump with a 21 SEER rating and 10 HSPF.

Air conditioning heat pumps


Carrier has various products, and the gas furnace model 59MN7 is their most advanced one. The Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency (AFUE) rated for this unit is about 98.5 percent.

This lets the furnace run at lower power for more extended periods. As a result, the machine will perform with greater energy efficiency and a quieter effect with more precise climate control.

Compared to Goodman's best gas furnace model, GMVM97 also has a high AFUE rate of 98 percent. This model is durable and capable of heavy-duty operation.

Plus, it is also an energy-efficient furnace.

Unit Tonnage Sizes

One can use the cooling capacity of an air conditioner to decide whether it is the right match for your room. The cooling power of an air conditioner is measured in British Thermal Units per Hour (BTU).

Carrier residential gas furnaces will come in various sizes, ranging from 44,000 to 120,000 BTU/h, whereas Goodman 40,000 to 100,000 BTU/h.

Unit Life Expectancy

You must properly maintain your Carrier heating and air conditioning unit to last 1525 years. A well-maintained AC unit will guarantee that it will not easily break down too soon.

Goodman air conditioners have a long life cycle due to their well-designed unit with sturdy materials. The average lifespan of a Goodman air conditioner is 1015 years.

Old rustic broken air conditioner


Carrier brands have decent warranty offers to the original owner of their product. You'll qualify for their guarantee if it meets their guidelines within 90 days after installation.

View Carrier's warranty policies below:

  • 10-year warranty for AC or heat pumps parts.
  • Limited 10-year condensing unit replacement for models 25VNA4 and 24VNA6.
  • 5-year warranty for the compressor (for actual owner only).

You'll obtain the best warranty for your HVAC unit if you follow the guidelines and sign for your Goodman HVAC warranty within 60 days after installation.

Most Goodman products come with the following features, depending on the model you purchase:

  • 10-year warranty on all parts.
  • Limited 10-year unit replacement warranty.
  • Lifetime warranty on compressor (as long as you own your home).
  • For models: GSC10, GSH10, GSC13, and GSH13 all are warranted for five years only.

Average Price And Installation Cost

Carrier AC is known for providing premium products with a pledge to perform long-term service in heating and cooling.

Total installation expenses for a new Carrier air conditioner range from $3,355 to $6,254.

Unlike its competitor Carrier, Goodman does not provide premium HVAC equipment; the price varies from $3,188 to $4,275 in installation charges.

If you're looking for a cost-effective and energy-efficient HVAC system, Goodman is a perfect choice.


Keeping the outdoor unit clean is a simple technique to save money and extend the life of an AC system.

These four primary Carrier AC maintenance steps can help keep the outdoor unit clean:

  1. Trim or remove shrubs or flowers that may obstruct airflow.
  2. Vacuum the coil once you've ensured that the AC system power is shut off.
  3. Using a garden hose, gently wash and clean the coil fins.
  4. AC's air filter must be checked and changed every 23 months.

An HVAC on the exterior of a building

For Goodman AC maintenance, kindly follow these steps below:

  1. You must change Goodman's air filter every 90 days.
  2. Cut and clean the grass that could hinder AC airflow.
  3. Clean any debris on the condensate drain.
  4. Clean the condenser coil fins.

Pro tip: Either of these two AC companies always suggest hiring an AC expert to do this job for you.

Product Availability

Carrier's products are divided into Infinity, Performance, and Comfort.

The Infinity series highlights the company's most advanced technology and features.

In comparison, the Performance series has certain modifications and marks as a good for individuals who don't need or want the more efficiency or technology.

Furthermore, the Comfort series is the most affordable option.

On the other hand, the Goodman also has unique, specific product such as SmartCoil, ComfortNet, and All-Aluminum Evaporator Coils.

SmartCoil is an advanced and efficient mix of 5mm copper tube and aluminum fin used in high-efficiency air conditioners and heat pumps.

ComfortNet is a communication control system that enables high-efficiency systems to perform at their best while also providing homeowners with unmatched control and operational precision.

Both brands of AC systems are offered in the United States through each company's nationwide dealer network or their online website (Carrier and Goodman).

What SEER Rating Should I Buy?

Generally, the greater the SEER rating, the more energy-efficient the unit is. Get a new AC unit based on these points. New units must now have at least a 13-point rating, mostly between 13 and 21, while some models may go much higher.

In contrast, older and lower-end models may receive lower points.

Nevertheless, the rating represents the HVAC unit's maximum efficiency. It is possible that it will not always work at that level.

What Is The Most Reliable Brand Of HVAC?

Male repair air conditioner at room

Heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) systems are typically overlooked until they fail. It becomes evident how critical these systems are for maintaining indoor comfort.

Because your HVAC system is likely the most costly thing in your home, choosing the proper brand to replace it is crucial.

As of this year, these are the world's top 10 most reliable HVAC producers:

  1. Carrier
  2. Bryant
  3. Goodman
  4. Lennox
  5. Trane
  6. Rheem
  7. American Standard
  8. York
  9. Frigidaire
  10. Amana and Coleman

To Wrap It Up

Woman turning on air conditioner with remote

A new AC unit is an expensive purchase for your home, but you've learned which brands offer the most energy-efficient products. We covered which serves the best warranty offers, and you've also found out which brands are on top in terms of durability.

We hope your learnings will help you choose your next air conditioner!

Made it this far? Check out these helpful related posts:

How To Set The Timer On A Carrier Air Conditioner

Carrier AC Fan Won’t Shut Off—What’s Wrong?

Share this article

One comment

  1. Goodmans are garbage units. Go to any Daikin warehouse supplier and you’ll see a mountain of coils in the back of their warehouse. They’re not even close in reliability to a Carrier/ICP unit.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *