Carrier Vs Trane: Which To Choose?

  • Post category:HVAC
  • Post comments:0 Comments

Carrier and Trane are two of the best brands of air conditioners. Both also have built outstanding reputations through the years. Choosing the best contractor to install an air conditioner is like selecting the best brand for you. It can be challenging to decide. We have researched everything you need to know about these brands to help you out!

If you are concerned about the cost of repairs, go for the Carrier brand. Trane parts can be hard to find, as some suppliers only sell OEM parts rather than generic parts that cost less. Therefore, the Trane brand may cost you more on repairs.

The price of a Carrier can vary based on the model and any installation costs. Most Trane models are more costly than the typical Carrier model, however.

Choosing the best brand is essential so you won't be able to regret it in the future. Keep reading as we will guide you on how you can save more and give you more detailed information about those brands.

A comparison between Carrier and Trane, Carrier Vs Trane: Which To Choose?

What do Carrier and Trane have in Common?

There are a few things that homeowners should consider when choosing the best AC units. However, it depends on what you value the most. One of the major factors is the cost of the AC brands, lifespan, energy efficiency, warranty, and unit size.

Let us look at what Trane and Carrier have in common.

  • Trane and Carrier's brands have different tiers: the basic, the better, and the best.
  • Both top brand models have innovative technology such as touch screen thermostats that can be connected through WIFI.
  • They have a compressor and insulation, which reduces sound.
  • They have cabinet vents to protect the coil from yard threats.
  • Both use R-410A refrigerant.
  • They both have corrosion resistance AC cabinets.

What are their differences?

While Trane and Carriers have a lot in common, they both have differences. Let us discuss them one by one.

Features

Here are the distinguishing features of the Carrier and Trane brands, and we will let you know how they differ from each other. 

Smart thermostat

It monitors and controls the HVAC system using iOS and Android apps.

  • Trane has the ComfortLink II thermostat while Carrier has the Infinity, Cor. 

Variable fan

It speeds up and slows down the output of the AC unit. It operates silently and has low capacities.

  • Both brands have these. 

Humidity control

It removes the excess humidity during the warm weather and makes your home comfortable at a high temperature.

  • Comfort R for Trane and Infinity Touch for Carrier. 

Smart home compatibility

The thermostats integrate a home automation system. It has Nexia, which controls those smart devices. Carrier's automation technology can control any HVAC brand when it comes to home security and safety using a range of sensors.

  • Trane brands are compatible with Nexia, while Carrier is for Alexa. 

Communication technology

The system allows the share of information rather than one-way communication from the thermostats. The entire AC communication system must be matched if you want to acquire an AC with a communication automation system.

  • Carrier and Trane both have communication technology, especially with their top models. 

Repair 

Air conditioner with maintenance tools and service reminder in residential back yard

You must know for now that any machinery breaks down. The life of your Carrier and Trane ranges from 10 years to 15 years. Trane and Carrier's central AC  can last 15 years to 20 years without the need for either minor or major repair. However, there are issues that you need to consider.

Carrier: Their parts are generally available at a reasonable price. This is where they separate themselves from the Trane brand, as Carrier is the best brand to purchase if you need repairs.

Trane: Trane parts are expensive in some areas. Suppliers and wholesalers only sell common parts. This is more likely in large metro areas and small towns.

The Price

Coins stack with balance scale

Trane and Carrier because they are considered equal when it comes to pricing. All of the ACs that belong to the three tiers are the same when it comes to price. In addition, both brands have their own authorized dealers. Thus, it is hard to shop for these brands online. When you look for these brands, ask your local dealers and then decide.

Installation

Air conditioner repairing by technician

Carrier has a significant advantage over Trane when it comes to installation. However, it is essential to know that both of these brands require an intensive installation process. Quality installation is as necessary as a quality unit, and Carrier has an advanced minimum certification requirement for its installers, unlike Trane.

What you Need to Know When Buying an AC 

For those purchasing an AC for the first time, the verdict may come easy. But the decision of which one to buy is not simple. There are many options to choose from – split type versus window type, smart versus basic, non-inverter versus inverter, not to mention the sizes and brands.

If all of these popped up in your mind, then we always got you covered.

Size

The first thing that you should consider is the size of the room. If the room is bigger, you need a high horsepower [HP]. This is crucial as it measures how cool the room should be, and it consumes more electricity in cooling the room.

If your unit doesn't have enough HP, it will work too much to cool the space. Your AC will turn on and off while exerting too much energy to maintain the temperature. Either way, you will end up paying more for your bill.

Furthermore, it is essential to check your home's load capacity. It must be able to handle the additional load of your air conditioner. Ask your electrician or your installer before installing.

Walls and windows

Outdoor window air conditioning unit

You decided to purchase a 1HP air conditioner, but should you get a split type or window type?

It is named a window-type air conditioner because it fits a window and requires little professional help to install. You have to make sure that the unit fits the window measurement.

On the other hand, a split-type unit needs a professional installation. You need to drill a hole into the wall large enough for the wirings and hose.

An outdoor unit should match the exterior wall. Electrical wirings must be safely fixed to avoid loose connections. Often, the entire installation costs more than the unit, depending on your contractor.

If done right, the split-type AC looks clean to the eyes.

Inverter or Non-inverter?

So now you got your 1 HP AC split-type, and you hear wonderful words about inverters. Indeed, inverter technology has remarkable energy efficiency benefits, especially with unplanned usage.

Inverters have built-in compressors that slow down and speed up depending on the temperature. Once the room reaches its desired temperature, the compressor will slow down. Then it consumes less energy compared to being at a full blast speed.

split type air conditioner on the wall

Non-inverters, on the other hand, speed up the compressor, turning off when it reaches the desired temperature. It turns on again when the temperature increases. The on and off the process of the non-inverter air conditioners consumes a high amount of energy, especially when being used over time.

So as you can see, inverters are the more cost-effective AC of choice. If you plan to use the unit for long hours, go for the inverter one. But if you are a busy type of person and leave the house every day, you better get the non-inverter type.

Long-term savings or short-term savings?

Time is money concept with coins and hourglass

If you are looking at the overall potential savings, there are a few things to consider. Inverter types are more expensive than non-inverter types. However, the energy efficiency will convert to money in the long run.

If your concern is the price tag of the AC unit, then choose a cheaper one worth your money.

Luckily, there are wise ways to buy an air conditioner without breaking the bank. You can opt for 0 percent interest rate promos if you are a credit cardholder. There are merchants who can offer you the best deals and in-store financing even if you don't own a credit card.

In Conclusion

Whether you want the Trane or Carrier brand of air conditioner, it is better to choose wisely. Consider the tips mentioned above and guides so you can go for a better one.

Regardless of your budget, do not forget to check the product warranty so you can save on repairs.

We have made it up to the end! You may check these post-related articles:  

What Temperature to Set Air Conditioner When Away

Do Ductless Air Conditioners Have Filters?

Leave a Reply