Lennox VS Trane Heat Pump: Which To Choose?

  • Post category:HVAC
  • Post comments:0 Comments

Lennox and Trane both make great heat pumps, but it can be difficult to choose which one is best for you. Before you make a major purchase, read ahead because we've already researched everything you need to know to make an informed decision on which heat pump to choose.

If you are looking for a heat pump with high efficiency, then Lennox is for you as they have 24 SEER-rated heat pumps. However, Lennox models are generally more expensive than Trane.

If durability and a quiet heat pump are your criteria, consider Trane because they can last for 20 years and they have models as quiet as 43 decibels. 

A heat pump is likely one of the most expensive equipment in your home, choosing the right company for a new one is important. We'll cover both brands and other heat-pump-related questions. Keep reading as we guide you to find a qualified heat pump for your needs.

Comparison between lennox and trane heat pump, Lennox VS Trane Heat Pump: Which To Choose?

Lennox and Trane Reviews

A heat pump is an outdoor component of a heating and cooling system. It can cool your home similarly to an air conditioner, but it can also heat it. It draws heat from the cold outside air and transfers it to the indoors during colder days, and it pulls heat from indoor air to cool your home during warmer days. 

Air conditioning units outside an apartment complex

Lennox and Trane are one of the best brands available in the market. Reading reviews is one of the requirements for making an informed decision.

Lennox

Since 1895, when they created the first steel-riveted furnace, Lennox has been providing clients with home climate control solutions. Their commitment to the pursuit of perfect air conditioning in clients' homes stems from their history of satisfying customers with high-quality products. 

Although their basic models have efficiencies of up to 24 SEER (Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio) scores, all of their models live up to high standards and help maintain their reputation for quality.

Lennox prides their products as one of the "Most Efficient ENERGY STAR" certified products in 2022 that reduce greenhouse gas emissions by meeting the United States' energy efficiency performance standards. And also, they claim that their products are exceptionally quiet.

Trane

Trane, unlike any other brand, lists its products by model number rather than series. In terms of owner satisfaction and reliability, Trane prides itself on being "Top Tier Excellent" for heat pumps in the  2019 and 2021 Summer Surveys offering sleek options that appeal to a client's focus on efficiency, volume, or value. 

Their heat pump products' SEER rating goes up to 20. According to their website, running high-efficiency Trane units in your home can save you up to 64% on energy costs.

Lennox and Trane Heat Pump Comparison

HVAC heating and air conditioning residential units or heat pumps

There are several factors and features of each brand to help you make an informed purchasing decision. When comparing heat pump options, the most important factors to consider are listed below. 

Output Capacity

Lennox units have a cooling and heating capacity of around 18,000 BTU to 60,000 BTU while Trane varies from 22,000 BTU to 60,000 BTUs.

Size

Lennox units are available in a variety of sizes, ranging from 1.5 to 5 tons and Trane 1.8 to 5 tons.

Efficiency Ratings

Lennox's heat pumps are Energy Star certified, and even the most basic merit unit has a SEER of 16. The top-of-the-line SL25XPV, on the other hand, has a SEER rating of 24.

Trane was rated as Most Efficient 2019 by ENERGY STAR and also, and the SEER rating is up to 20.

Average Running Decibels

Lennox's systems average 70 decibels, with the quietest models reaching 64 decibels. On the other hand, Trane heat pumps are among the quietest, with the lowest noise levels of 43 decibels.

Specialized Features

  • Lennox has a Silent Comfort Technology which adjusts heating and cooling for minimal energy output. And also, dual-fuel capability.
  • Trane has the following features:
    • ComfortLink II
    • Sound Insulating Compressor
    • Refrigerant Cooled Inverter
    • Climatuff Compressor
    • Spine Fin coil
    • WeatherGuard Top
    • WeatherGuard Top Accessory
    • DuraTuff Basepan
    • TruComfort Variable Speed Systems
    • Simplified Two-Wire Connection

Unit Price

Lennox heat pumps cost between $2,200 and $5,500. These units cost between $4,000 and $9,000 to install. While Trane heat pump prices, including installation, range from $4,600 to $10,000.

The bottom line is that the cost of the heat pump depends on the type and model you choose, as well as the cost of installation in your area. There's a good chance the model that's right for you is one that Trane undercuts Lennox on price or vice versa.

Parts/Repair cost

Both brands have the same parts/repair cost which ranges from $15 to $150 (low); $250 to $600 (average); $800 to $1,700 (high).

Lifespan

Lennox heat pump lasts around the average of 10 to 15 years while Trane heat pump has an average lifespan of 15 to 20 years, but it can last much longer if properly maintained. Because Trane heat pumps are built to last due to their high-quality materials. 

Overall, Trane is the heat pump that can last the longest. 

Warranty

The warranty of Lennox heat pump at minimum is five years on covered parts plus the compressor and 20 years for the heat exchanger part. The warranty in Lennox is valid even if it is not registered.

However, the Dave Lennox Signature series includes a 10 years warranty on covered parts, as well as 10 years for compressor warranty and a lifetime limited warranty on the heat exchanger.

Meanwhile, Trane has a five years warranty for a unit that has no registration within 60 days of being installed and 10 years for the registered one within 60 days but the length of coverage varies by product.

In Trane, it only covers parts that may fail due to a manufacturer's defect, but not the labor required to replace them. Trane has strict rules for the warranty because it is only valid if the unit is installed and serviced by Trane-certified technicians.

Maintenance Needs

Air conditioner repairman works on home unit

Lennox recommended that only authorized dealers should clean the coils, remove debris, and straighten the coil fins on a regular basis, as well as change or clean the air filters.

These things can be done by a technician during annual or seasonal maintenance to keep your heat pump in good working order. Expect to pay around $100 for an annual tune-up.

Trane recommends that you have a maintenance check routine, clear the area around the outdoor unit of any debris, regularly change your filters and a programmable thermostat should be installed.

Also, Trane advised at least once a year to contact your local dealer for a preventative maintenance check-up because there are things that only they can do or only they know.

Availability

Lennox has two types of heat pumps: Single-stage and multi-stage heat pumps. Both types are divided into three categories: Signature, Elite and Merit.

Trane heat pumps have three distinct product lines: XR, XL, and XV series. 

Both brands of heat pumps are available through each company's nationwide dealer network in the United States or you can visit each of them on their online platform (Lennox and Trane).

What size heat pump do I need for my house?

Air conditioning heat pumps on the side of a house

Your heat pump will most likely not work properly if it is too small for your home. Because the heat pump will struggle to heat and cool your home, you may end up paying a higher utility bill.

On the other hand, If your heat pump is too large for your home, it will produce more energy than you require, wasting energy and lowering efficiency.

The general rule of thumb, every  500 sq. ft. of your house requires one ton of air conditioning. And one ton is equivalent to 12,000 BTU of the heat pump.

Which heat pump is the most reliable?

It can be challenging to choose the best heat pump brands. According to the research by U.S. News, Lennox placed at number four and Trane is fifth of the Best HVAC Companies of 2022.

Lennox got a higher place in the survey because it makes the most energy-efficient heat pumps on the market, making it a good choice for those looking to reduce their monthly utility bills.

Air heat pump and house

Meanwhile, Trane has a good impression too because of its quiet operating sound levels and its design that lasts beyond the typical 15 years lifespan with proper maintenance.

Final thoughts 

A new heat pump is a significant investment for your home. It doesn't have to be a terrifying experience after reading this article. Now you can choose the right heat pump with the knowledge gained here.

Choosing the right heat pump also necessitates selecting the right installation company. Either Lennox or Trane, choose a company that will assist you before, during, and after the sale.

If you enjoy reading this article, please do check for more of our posts which will help you troubleshoot your heat pump and find more other heat pump comparisons to other brands:

Lennox Heat Pump Not Working – What To Do?

Trane Vs Bosch Heat Pump: Which To Choose?

 

Leave a Reply