Mr. Cool Vs. Goodman – Which To Choose?

Disclosure: We may get commissions for purchases made through links in this post.

Choosing a new air conditioning unit might be offputting with the vast array of options, especially different brands. Let's say that you've narrowed your choices; however, now face a dilemma of choosing between two brands—Mr. Cool and Goodman. Today, we'll be helping you distinguish the pros and cons of each brand, helping you decide which one suits your needs better.

If you already have experience installing an HVAC system unit, then a Mr. Cool system unit is the one for you as they heavily promote DIY installation. However, many DIYers claim a bad experience with this brand. In contrast, Goodman is part of the top ten most reliable brands for HVAC systems; hence, we highly recommend going for Goodman instead.

Now that you know which brand to go for, keep reading as we further elaborate on the reasons why we recommend Goodman. Additionally, further questions in this post might answer some that you have on your mind when buying an HVAC system.

A comparison between Mr. Cool and Goodman air conditioner, Mr. Cool Vs. Goodman - Which To Choose?

Is Mr. Cool A Bad HVAC System?

Mr. Cool is an HVAC system brand founded in 2014. Their main selling point is a do-it-yourself HVAC system for your homes, with products ranging from compact HVAC units to central system units. However, we've seen many reviews stating that users have had problems with the product as soon as they received it.

From missing parts to self-disintegrating after one day of use, it does seem pretty intimidating to invest your hard-earned money into this brand. At the same time, these problems are not widespread; however, users have reported bad to downright horrible experiences while dealing with customer service.

With these problems, we don't recommend getting Mr. Cool. Although your mileage may vary, if you'll be investing a reasonable sum of money, you might as well invest in a reputable brand with good warranty coverage.

What Makes Goodman A Good HVAC System?

Goodman HVAC unit on the outside of a vacation house

The Goodman Company, another HVAC company, was founded in 1975. With well over 47 years of experience, their longevity tells you the story of the quality of their products. Daikin, a leading global HVAC manufacturer, currently owns Goodman, further reinforcing their reputation as a reliable brand.

According to HVAC Guide For Homeowners on YouTube, they mentioned that Goodman has a tarnished reputation due to the accessibility of Goodman products.

Ease of access with Goodman products allows you to hire a cheap technician to install the HVAC system for you, which in turn might cause problems in the long run if improperly installed.

Furthermore, other dealers of Goodman strengthen this idea that Goodman gets a bad reputation due to the company selling their units to anyone. According to the dealer on Reddit, no matter how good a piece of equipment is, it will give you problems for years if it undergoes improper installation.

Besides those points, Goodman HVAC systems are cheap but reliable. It's basically the Ford and Chevrolet of HVAC systems. It doesn't have all the advanced features of high-end brands such as Carrier or American Standard; however, it is an excellent builder HVAC system for its worth and features.

Should You Hire A Technician To Install An HVAC System?

Multi-ethnic team of blue collar air conditioner repairmen at work

While installing an HVAC system by yourself may sound enticing and easy to do, it's not. Mr. Cool promotes their products as easy to install and something that you can do yourself; however, we wouldn't recommend this. There are multiple reasons why an HVAC company trains technicians to install a customer's unit for them, and here are some of them.

Improves The Efficiency of The System

Professional technicians size up your room to determine what type of system is optimal and how much cooling power your room needs. To further explain this, an HVAC system that is too small will not work effectively if the room it's trying to regulate is too big.

Meanwhile, an HVAC system that is too big for the room it's trying to work on will mean that you're wasting money on initial expenses plus much more expensive recurring electricity costs.

These professional technicians will be able to save you more money in the long run and save you the risk of having an uncomfortable experience with an undersized HVAC system.

Reduced Risk Of Future Problems

As mentioned in the statement above, incorrectly installed HVAC systems will cause trouble and can lead to damage in the long run. Most instances of incorrectly installed systems will lead to the system overworking itself. The resulting damage can range from minor to significant issues that require costly repairs.

Efficient and Time-Saving Service Instead of DIY

Hand depositing clock in piggy bank

Nowadays, the saying that "time is gold" has never been so true. Suppose you'll be installing an HVAC system yourself. In that case, it can prove to be a challenge, especially if you are not that familiar with the installation process, the terminology, the parts, and not to mention the experience and the cost of power tools that you need to have.

Safety Precautions During Installation

Upon hiring a professional technician, the first thing that they'll do is clear the room, making sure that there's nothing that poses as a hazard during the installation. This safety is valuable and something that you wouldn't guarantee if you're doing your first DIY HVAC system installation.

At the same time, technicians will be able to safely deal with wiring the HVAC system to an electrical circuit board which is dangerous to inexperienced people. They will also be wearing proper PPE (Personal Protective Equipment). Please take note that it's not worth putting the safety of you and other family members to install an HVAC system.

Hvac technician inspecting an condensing unit

Expertise in Dealing With Installation Problems

Running into trouble during installation is something that these professional technicians are used to. As for someone who is inexperienced with these problems, you'd probably be scrambling and looking for the manual to try to resolve these.

Not all issues that you will encounter during installation are in the manual. So if you are doing it on your own, be very careful about the whole process of installation.

Not to mention that if you were to damage a part during installation, then you'd most likely have to pay to replace the damaged part and, of course, wait for that part to arrive before carrying on with the installation. Professional technicians will be able to solve these problems with ease and get your home comfortable in a timely manner.

Best Brands for HVAC Systems

If the testimonies from technicians and dealers are not enough to convince you to go for a Goodman HVAC system, here are other alternatives. Note that some of these are more expensive than Goodman; USNews handpicked these brands based on a scale of one to five.

  • Carrier
  • Bryant
  • Lennox
  • Trane
  • Rheem
  • American Standard
  • York
  • Frigidaire
  • Amana
  • Coleman

These HVAC companies are already known for their reliability, power efficiency, and excellent warranty coverage. Being part of this list is already a great indication that the brand is a beautiful choice, and Goodman ranks third in this list.

It's also worth mentioning that Daikin owns Amana as well, which, as mentioned earlier, is a parent company of Goodman.

In Conclusion

Choosing a brand for your HVAC unit is difficult, but here's a great rule of thumb. Always go with what's reliable even though it's a bit more expensive. It saves you a lot of time and money and even eliminates the headache you'll be experiencing once you run into problems.

Alongside getting a reputable brand of the HVAC system, make sure that you hire a professional when installing an HVAC system as it saves you from the hassle of the installation process, guarantees successful installation and safety for you and your family members.

If you found this article helpful, then check out these other articles that we have!

Leave a Reply