Ducane Vs Trane Vs Carrier: Which To Choose?

  • Post category:HVAC
  • Post comments:0 Comments

An HVAC system controls your home's temperature. Choosing the right system is an important decision. We have researched to help you choose whether Ducane, Trane, or Carrier is the best brand for you.

Choosing an HVAC system should not be taken lightly. Quality and efficiency should be priorities. When picking HVAC brands, you should consider how well they perform in terms of AC, heat pump, and furnace efficiency. You should also consider warranties and prices. 

Carrier is known for having lasting HVAC units, while Trane offers several warranty options. On the other hand, Ducane is well-known for having good-quality ACs at nearly half the price of other brands. Using these parameters, you should be able to weigh which brand will suit your needs. 

Knowing what brand is best for your home in terms of heating and cooling is important. Is it Ducane, Trane, or Carrier? If you want more information about these brands, continue reading!

A photo collage of a Ducane, Trane and a Carrie air conditioner on ground, Ducane Vs Trane Vs Carrier: Which To Choose?

Ducane: Overview

Ducane is located in the United States. Due to its dependability and affordability, as well as the durability of its products, Ducane is a popular choice. 

Check out this Ducane Air Conditioner on Amazon.

Air Conditioner Efficiency

The SEER ratings of Ducane's air conditioners run up to 18.0. The current minimum government standard is 13 SEER.

Heat Pump Efficiency

There are two different ratings for heat pumps: SEER and HSPF. The SEER and HSPF ratings of the Ducane heat pump range from 8.0 HSPF and 13.0 SEER up to 9.2 HSPF.

Furnace Efficiency

How much heat a furnace produces is determined by its efficiency. The AFUE of a Ducane furnace normally ranges from 78% to 98%.

Ducane Warranty

Ducane offers a range of warranty benefits, including a 10-year warranty on:

  • Heat exchangers on gas and oil furnaces
  • Compressor and parts of the air conditioner
  • Heat pumps on the compressor and components.

A five-year limited warranty on parts and a 20-year limited warranty on heat exchangers will be provided on unregistered equipment if you don't register within 60 days of installation.

How Much Does Ducane Cost?

Air Conditioner

The cost of a Ducane AC will depend on the size, type, and features of the model. In addition to that, installation can also be another payment depending on your ductwork, the size of your home, and installation difficulty.

A Ducane air conditioner typically costs between $3,040 and $8,340, plus the installation. Ask a local HVAC expert for an estimate to get the most accurate cost information.

Heat Pump

The cost of a Ducane heat pump depends on the unit and features of the model, plus another installation fee.

The least expensive unit could cost $2,179 to $3,169 plus the installation cost, and the most expensive unit could cost $3,050 to $4,125 plus the installation cost.

Furnace

The cost of a Ducane furnace will depend on the model, size, AFUE rating, and features. In addition to that, installation and placement will affect the total amount.

A Ducane furnace costs around $1,000 up to $1,950 plus the installation fee. You can ask a local HVAC professional for an accurate price.

Trane: Overview

 A new air conditioner unti was just installed outside a residential home.

Trane is known for its dependability, high quality standards, advanced technology, and on-time delivery. 

Air Conditioner Efficiency

Trane AC SEER ranges from 14.5 SEER up to 22 SEER. The performance of your system can vary based on the size of your home, your ductwork, and other variables.

Heat Pump Efficiency

A Trane heat pump SEER rating ranges from 14.0 to 20.0, and the HSPF ranges from 8.2 to 10.0.

Furnace Efficiency

The lowest AFUE offers on the Trane furnace would be up to 80%, and the highest rating is up to 97.3%.

Trane Warranty

There are three kinds of warranties for Trane products, and these are base limited, registered limited, and optional extended warranty.

  • The base limited warranty has a 5-12 months coverage period
  • The registered limited warranty has 10 years of coverage on interior working parts and outdoor coils.
  • Optional extended warranty consists of labor expenses. This feature can be purchased in five-, 10-, or 12-year increments

How Much Does Trane Cost?

Heating and air conditioning inverters on the side of a condo.

Air Conditioner

The cost of a Trane AC will depend on the model's size, type, and features. In addition to that, installation can also be another payment depending on your ductwork, the size of your home, and installation difficulty.

The least expensive unit installation costs would be around $3,400 to $5,400, and the most expensive are about $8,000 to $13,000.

Heat Pump

The cost of a Trane heat pump depends on the unit and features of the model, size, and installation fee. The least expensive unit installation could cost $4,000 to $5,600, and the most expensive is around $6,800 to $9,000

Furnace

The cost of a Trane furnace will depend on the model, size, AFUE rating, and features. In addition to that, installation and placement will affect the total amount. 

The least expensive unit installation could cost $1,800 to $3,000; the most expensive is around $4,500 to $7,500.

Carrier: Overview

Technicians tools placed in front of multiple Carrier Infinity series HVAC Air conditioning condensing units on a roof top of a commercial building.

The Carrier brand has a 16 HVAC system. These units are some of the quietest, most energy-efficient on the market. The heat pumps and furnaces feature innovation and reliability. However, Carrier can be more expensive than the other brands.

Air Conditioner Efficiency

The highest SEER rating Carrier offers is 26, and the lowest is 13.

Heat Pump Efficiency

The highest SEER rating of a Carrier heat pump is 24, and the HSPF rating is up to 13.

Furnace Efficiency

Most Carrier furnaces have an AFUE value exceeding 80%, going up to 98.5%.

Carrier Warranty

Carrier offers three lines: Infinity, Performance, and Comfort. The standard warranty of Carrier is 10 years for parts. Major components have a warranty of 20 years or a lifetime.

To qualify for the full range of warranty benefits, you must register your product.

  • Heat pumps have a 10-year warranty on parts and compressors.
  • The air conditioners have a 10-year warranty on parts and compressors.
  • A furnace warranty has a 10-year warranty on the parts and 20 years or a lifetime for the heat exchanger.

How Much Does Carrier Cost?

Air Conditioner

The cost of a Carrier AC will depend on what type of Carrier AC unit you choose. A central air conditioner could cost $3,000 to $15,000, including the installation.

A ductless mini split could cost $2,000 to $10,500, including the installation, and a geothermal could cost $12,000 to $45,000 including the installation.

Heat Pump

For heat pump costs, the prices will depend on the size, the type of heat pump, the SEER AND HSPF ratings, and where it's installed. However, the installation could cost around $3,000 up to $15,000 or more.

Furnace

The price of the furnace will depend on the unit and the installation. The least expensive would be $996, and the most expensive would be $2,650. Installation costs can run from $2,382 up to $5,589.

What SEER Rating Is Best?

A SEER is used for rating air conditioners and heat pumps. A 14 or higher SEER rating is recommended.

The average efficiency rating for an AC is 16, and a 23 SEER rating is the highest for energy efficiency. An advantage of having a high SEER rating is that the unit uses less energy, reducing your power bill costs.

What HSPF Rating Is Best?

An HSPF (Heating Seasonal Performance Factor) is used for rating a heat pump. There are heat pumps with 10 HSPF or even higher.

The minimum HSPF rating is 7.7. A good HSFP rating is 8.5 to earn an Energy Star label. A higher HSPF rating is very efficient because less energy is used.

What AFUE Rating Is Best?

AFUE (Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency) ratings measure a furnace's energy efficiency.

A heating system is regarded as low-efficiency if its rating is below 80%, mid-efficiency if it is between 80% and 83%, and high-efficiency if it is between 90% and 98.5%.

Conclusion

The three brands covered in this post offer quality central air conditioners, heat pumps, and furnaces. It is important to choose one that has the best warranty and best efficiency rating. We hope this article helps you make an informed decision.

You might also find these topics helpful:

How To Clean Ducane AC Unit

Amana Vs. Trane: Which AC To Choose?

Leave a Reply